2009
Pink Brick Runner-Up:
Archbishop George Niederaruer
The San Francisco LGBT Pride
Celebration Committee hurled a second Pink Brick at
Archbishop George Niederauer.
The
Pink Brick is an annual 'award' given each year to a person
or institution whose actions are deemed to have
caused significant harm to the LGBT community.
Pride’s membership voted at their June meeting to
throw a second Brick at Niederauer by awarding him
the title of “Pink Brick Runner-Up.”
San Francisco Pride’s Board President
Mikayla Connell:
“After the first Pink Brick, the
Pride Committee received thoughtful feedback
from the community that Archbishop Niederauer’s
actions in support of Proposition 8 caused
significant harm to the LGBT community. We hope
that with this Pink Brick, we can educate the
community about Archbishop Niederauer’s work to
deny LGBT couples equal protection under the
law. Archbishop Niederauer’s support of
Proposition 8, which is not representative of
all faith communities or even of all Catholics,
has only served to harm LGBT families, many of
whom are Catholic themselves. We find it
extremely disturbing that a Church leader in a
country founded on the principles of freedom,
including religious freedom, would use his
position in the church to fight against the
secular right of LGBT people to form legally
recognized marriages. No person’s religious
faith should define the secular legal rights of
other people in the community. All faiths have
the right to define what sacramental marriage is
for their faithful – no church has the right to
decide what secular marriage is for all other
people. LGBT Americans deserve the promise of
America – the promise of equality. And so
today, we throw a metaphorical Pink Brick at
Archbishop Niederauer for his attempts to deny
us that secular equality. However, we wouldn’t
want the award to go to his head, so Pride’s
membership has decided he is only the
Runner-Up. We sincerely hope that the
Archbishop comes to embrace the LGBT community
instead of work against it, and that we will
never have to toss another metaphorical brick at
him again – Pride would be happy to engage the
Archbishop about how the Church and LGBT
communities can support each other on behalf of
all the faithful, be they straight or LGBT.”
2008 Pink Brick Recipient: Bill O'Reilly
Pink Brick Delivered!
Watch Board President Mikayla Connell deliver the
Pink Brick to Bill O'Reilly in person on his show on
June 4, 2008:
YOUR
PINK BRICK MESSAGES TO BILL O'REILLY At this
year's 2008 San Francisco Pride Celebration, we
collected hundreds upon hundreds of signatures on a statement
that the Pride Celebration Committee will be sending to
Bill O'Reilly as part of his Pink Brick recognition.
Here is the statement:
Dear Mr. O'Reilly,
Your efforts to mislead your viewers and
listeners about issues regarding the
lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender (LGBT)
community does more than just leave a
misleading impression—it reinforces
ignorance about and hatred toward our
community. In the past year you have
misconstrued positive representations of
LGBT people to be recruitment campaigns and
manufactured news about the supposed threat
of lesbian gangs. Our community, in the
face of widespread discrimination, needs
your support, not sensationalism, in our
pursuit for equal rights and an end to
discrimination. I urge you to uphold your
journalistic duties to provide coverage that
is truly fair and honors the human dignity
of all people, regardless of their sexuality
and gender identity.
Many of you added your own personal message, so we thought we'd share just a sample
of what folks from all over the world had to say
to Mr. O'Reilly at this year's San Francisco
LGBT Pride Celebration:
"I am an Australian and think
people as close-minded as you should open up
and live a little."
-Melbourne, Australia
"May you transcend your
narrow mind!"
-Oakland, California
"Mr. O'Reilly, all Americans,
even the most conservative, have gay family
members. I simply ask that you speak with
members of your own family and consider them
before you fan the flames of hatred that [a]ffect
us all."
-San Francisco, California
"[...] I hope one day you
realize everyone should have equal rights."
-San Diego, California
"Us Brits don't approve of
gay bashing in the 21st century!"
-London, United Kingdom
"Two years ago you denounced
a party at my school as immoral, put video
of it online, and criticized us! That party
was a total celebration of life! Before you
criticize something, think about what you're
destroying."
-Providence, Rhode Island
"The type of hate you are
spreading across the airwaves is breaking
down the sense of community that this
country was built on."
-Houston, Texas
"Let peace and love guide
you, not hate."
-Bakersfield, California
"Love is good - give it a try
someday."
-Boston, Massachusetts
"Wake up and realize that it
is 2008. you have lost your bigoted war and
just make a terrible impression for your
countrymen. Shame!"
-London, United Kingdom
"Mr. O'Reilly, our 'Pink
Brick' is too good for someone as bigoted as
you!"
-Houston, Texas
"The world would be a better
place if we could only be inclusive, not
exclusive [...]."
-San Francisco, California
Bill O'Reilly Unlike past recipients,
Bill O'Reilly's receipt of this award
cannot be attributed to any one stance
or event. His consistent efforts
to mislead his viewers and listeners
about issues regarding the LGBT
community and LGBT people does more than
just leave a misleading impression—it
reinforces ignorance about and hatred of
our community. While there
are many instances to which we might
refer, his
lesbian
gang segment on The
O'Reilly Factor on June 21, 2007
epitomizes the way in which O'Reilly has
discarded truth in favor of baseless
slander and fear-mongering.
Not mentioned in this segment on
"lesbian gangs" was the fact that there is no
evidence that the women involved in the attack on
Wayne Buckle were members of any criminal gang. Also
unmentioned was the fact that the women were
responding to Buckle's unwelcomed sexual advances
which resulted in his flicking a cigarette at the
women after one of them rebuffed his sexual
overtures..
That segment also featured in
the background a highly provocative, looped
video of women fighting.
The insinuation was that these women
represented the group Dykes Taking Over, which
O'Reilly's segment indicated was an example of a
lesbian gang. Had the audio accompanied that
video, which is widely available on internet video
sites, it would have quickly revealed that these
young women were fighting over a boy—so much for
violent lesbians.
Sensationalism trumped truth. The
footage was provocative and meant to instill fear
and in so doing, to drive up ratings by means of
unabashed sensationalism. It is extremely
difficult to conclude from the available evidence
that the purpose of the segment was to describe any
real trends in gangs across the country when the
evidence of which O'Reilly made use was faulty and
misleading. (You
can review the video with audio here)
ABOUT THE PINK BRICK
The Pink Brick recipient is a person or institution
which has done significant harm to the interests of
LGBT peoples to receive the Pink Brick. Usually, this person
is selected by public vote for receipt of the Pink
Brick, a faux “award” that represents the first
brick hurled at the Stonewall Rebellion on June 27,
1969..
How the Prink Brick Recipient is Chosen
Typically, the general public nominates potential recipients
for the Pink Brick in January. Public polling is
conducted in March when anyone, anywhere can
participate in the Pink Brick vote.
In 2008, the Brick went to Bill O'Reilly for his
sensationalist reporting on the LGBT community.
George W. Bush received the Pink Brick in 2007 for
his support of an amendment to the Constitution
defining marriage as between a man and a woman and
in 2006 Arnold Schwarzenegger had the Brick hurled
his way for his veto of a bill that would have
allowed same-sex marriage in California.
In 2008, a majority of those community members
polled elected to hurl the Pink Brick at Bill
O'Reilly, beating out the Human Rights Campaign who
came in second and Iranian President Mahmoud
Ahmadinejad.
PAST
PINK BRICK RECIPIENTS
The following were the Pink Brick Recipients for
in years past: